With the NBA regular season tipping off in just a week, it’s time to dive into the burning questions that could define the year ahead. Who will emerge as the unexpected MVP contender? And more importantly, who has the most to prove on the court? These are the storylines that will keep fans on the edge of their seats.
But here’s where it gets controversial: while Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, Nikola Jokić, and Luka Dončić are the obvious preseason favorites, there’s a growing debate about who else could crash the MVP party. Could it be Jalen Brunson, fresh off leading the Knicks to the Eastern Conference finals? Or perhaps Anthony Edwards, the young phenom ready to take the next step? And let’s not forget Donovan Mitchell, whose Cavaliers could dominate the East. Each of these players has a compelling case, but only one can take home the trophy. Who’s your pick?
To explore this, we’ve gathered insights from three of The Athletic’s top NBA writers: William Guillory, Law Murray, and Josh Robbins. Each brings a unique perspective on the players and storylines that could shape the season.
Jalen Brunson: The Dark Horse MVP?
William Guillory makes a bold case for Jalen Brunson. After leading the Knicks to their first Eastern Conference finals since 2000, Brunson is poised to thrive in a weaker East. With the Celtics, Pacers, and Bucks expected to take a step back, the Knicks could emerge as a 60-win team. Add in new head coach Mike Brown’s modern offensive schemes, and Brunson could become even more efficient. Plus, as last season’s Clutch Player of the Year, he’s already proven he can deliver in high-pressure moments. But is that enough to win MVP? And this is the part most people miss: the New York hype machine could be the X-factor that propels him into the conversation.
Anthony Edwards: The Next Superstar?
Law Murray argues that Anthony Edwards is the obvious choice. At just 24, Edwards has already played in back-to-back Western Conference finals and is primed for a breakout season. With the Timberwolves relying heavily on him, Edwards has the usage and narrative to make a strong MVP case. But here’s the catch: he needs to take his game to the next level consistently. Can he do it? If so, the Michael Jordan Trophy could be his.
Donovan Mitchell: The Proven Contender?
Josh Robbins highlights Donovan Mitchell, who finished fifth in MVP voting last season and is in his prime. With the Cavaliers projected to finish first in the East, Mitchell has the team success and individual talent to make a serious run. But there’s a twist: Mitchell still hasn’t advanced past the second round of the playoffs. Until he does, will he get the credit he deserves? This season could be his chance to silence the doubters.
Who Has the Most to Prove?
While Mitchell is a strong candidate, Murray points out that he’s still chasing his first conference finals appearance. Meanwhile, Joel Embiid’s health remains a question mark. As Robbins notes, Embiid’s production is undeniable, but injuries have limited him to just 58 games over the past two seasons. If he can’t stay healthy, the scrutiny will only intensify. Is this the year he finally puts it all together?
The Under-the-Radar X-Factors
Beyond the stars, there are players who could swing their team’s fortunes. Guillory highlights Amen Thompson, whose defensive prowess and offensive potential make him a key piece for the Rockets. Murray points to Franz Wagner, whose two-way play could elevate the Magic in the East. And Robbins believes Cam Johnson’s 3-point shooting could be the difference-maker for the Nuggets in a tight Western Conference race.
Rookie Watch: Beyond the Hype
While Cooper Flagg and Dylan Harper dominate the rookie conversation, other newcomers are worth watching. Guillory is intrigued by the contrast between Kon Knueppel’s fundamentals and LaMelo Ball’s flash. Murray keeps an eye on Egor Dёmin, the Nets’ lottery pick who could play a significant role. And Robbins is fascinated by Ace Bailey, whose potential is sky-high if he can refine his game.
The Comeback Kid
Finally, who’s due for a bounce-back season? Guillory wonders if Paul George still has one more great year left in him. Murray believes Brandon Ingram, after a injury-plagued season, could thrive in Toronto. And Robbins thinks Bradley Beal, now with the Clippers, has a golden opportunity to redeem himself.
So, who’s your MVP pick? And which player do you think will surprise us all? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments—agree or disagree, the debate is wide open!
