Terrified of applying eye shadow and dealing with messy fallout? Imagine transforming your eyes effortlessly with a product that blends like a dream and stays put all day—welcome to the world of cream eye shadows, where simplicity meets stunning results!
But here's where it gets controversial: many swear by expensive powders, but I'm here to challenge that notion and show you how affordable creams can deliver just as much magic. Let's dive in, and I'll guide you through my top picks across different budgets, making it easy for beginners to understand why these formulas are game-changers. No more intimidating techniques—just smooth application and vibrant color that lasts.
As a beauty enthusiast, I've put cream eye shadows to the test at every price level, and the budget-friendly ones are absolute winners, especially for party nights when you want that extra sparkle without the hassle.
TESTED
EYE INSIGHT!
Discover tips for prioritizing body care this winter too
Tara Ledden (https://www.thesun.co.uk/author/tara-ledden/), Beauty Editor
Published: 19:00, 11 Oct 2025
Intimidated by eye shadow? I'm convinced I can win you over with just one type—cream shadow. It eliminates all that frustrating fallout and blends incredibly smoothly. Allow me to share three standout options I've personally vetted.
BUDGET OPTION
No7 Pro Artist Cream Eyeshadow, £11.95 for 3.4g, available at boots.com (https://www.thesun.co.uk/topic/boots/)
3
This No7 collection stands out as one of the most impressive makeup launches I've seen recently. I haven't encountered a single item in the line that disappointed, and this cream eyeshadow ranks among the finest, proving that a low-cost tag doesn't mean compromising on quality. For beginners, you might need to apply a couple of coats to achieve the true intensity shown in the packaging, but the shimmering effect kicks in right away—ideal for festive occasions without overwhelming your everyday look. If your skin is on the oily side like mine, I recommend using a primer for extended wear with its creamy texture, but overall, these are fantastic and user-friendly.
MID-RANGE CHOICE
Lisa Eldridge Liquid Lurex Eyeshadow, £21 for 2.8ml, found at lisaeldridge.com
3
Generally, I lean toward cream eyeshadows in a pot format, like the other recommendations here. They're typically more straightforward to use compared to liquid versions such as this. However, every guideline has its exceptions, and if there's anyone poised to change my stance, it's the legendary makeup artist Lisa Eldridge (https://www.thesun.co.uk/fabulous/33046171/lisa-eldridge-pinpoint-concealer-trial/). This formula mixes just as effortlessly but sets quicker, which is a boon for those with oily eyelids or fine lines, as it resists creasing even in heavily glittery shades that feel weightless. I've experimented with nearly all the colors in the collection, and each one complements my skin tone flawlessly—a true standout rarity.
I'm your over-50 makeup teacher - 3 eyeshadow mistakes you're making on crepey, saggy eyes that are aging you
LUXURY PICK
Kulfi Zari Eyes Eyeshadow, £30 for 5g, available at spacenk.com
3
These eyeshadows could very well be the pinnacle of what I've tested. Their high pigmentation means even a minuscule dab covers broadly, ensuring the pot endures for ages (just keep those hygiene experts at bay!). They're as shimmery as any powdered alternative I've tried, yet entirely fuss-free, with the glitter embedded in the cream to prevent any dusty residue during application and to facilitate seamless blending. The product glides on like velvet, but once it sets, it transforms into a powder-like finish that avoids smudging for oily lids.
And this is the part most people miss: while luxury brands often boast superior staying power, these budget and mid-range creams prove that innovation isn't always tied to high costs—sparking debate on whether we should all rethink our spending on makeup.
PICK OF THE WEEK
I'm committed to elevating my body care routine this winter, and the UK debut of Saltair this week is making that goal attainable. Founded by model and body-positivity advocate Iskra Lawrence (https://www.thesun.co.uk/who/iskra-lawrence/), the line offers a complete spa experience at home, featuring premium body oils, butters, scrubs, and even an effective AHA deodorant—the rare natural option that truly delivers results. Check it out at spacenk.com (http://spacenk.com/).
What do you think—should natural, affordable products like these cream shadows challenge the dominance of high-end brands, or do you believe quality always comes with a hefty price tag? Is it controversial to prioritize body care over makeup, or are they equally essential for self-care? Share your opinions in the comments below; I'd love to hear if you've tried similar items or have a favorite hack for oily lids!
